Forest Plan Revisions in the Sierra Nevada Will Determine Fate of Potential Wilderness and Wild Rivers
The U.S. Forest Service has released for public review and comment draft management plans for nearly 4 million acres of public lands on the Inyo, Sequoia, and Sierra National Forests in the eastern and southern Sierra Nevada. These draft Forest Plans address many different land and resource management issues, including the identification of and potential agency recommendations to protect additional Wilderness and Wild & Scenic Rivers.
At stake in the plan revision process are 1.5 million acres of roadless lands that could be protected as Wilderness and nearly 870 miles of rivers and streams determined eligible for Wild & Scenic River protection.
Unfortunately, the Forest Service’s “preferred” Alternative B recommends no Wilderness on the Sequoia and Sierra Forests and only about 37,000 acres on the Inyo Forest. But Alternative C recommends a reasonable amount of new Wilderness – 315,531 acres on the Inyo, 206,904 acres on the Sequoia, and 220,641 acres on the Sierra. That’s a total of 743,076 acres or a bit more than half of the 1.4 million acres of roadless lands that were inventoried.
Even with the more conservation-oriented Alternative C, some key areas remain unprotected particularly on the Sequoia Forest, including nearly 50,000 acres of potential additions to the existing Bright Star Wilderness and the nearly pristine watersheds of Rattlesnake and Durwood Creeks in the potential southern addition to the Golden Trout Wilderness
Fortunately, all 870 miles of rivers and streams identified by the agency as eligible for potential Wild & Scenic River protection are included in all the action alternatives identified in the draft plans, including the preferred Alternative C. That means the Forest Service will be required to manage these eligible streams to protect their free flowing character and outstanding natural and cultural values regardless of which alternative is chosen. Unfortunately, even this expansion inventory leaves out key streams, including Dexter Canyon on the Inyo Forest, Salmon and Trout Creeks on the Sequoia Forest, and lower Dinkey Creek on the Sierra.
The extended public comment periods for these draft plans ended in November 2016. To ensure that more than 2.5% of the unprotected roadless inventory in this iconic landscape is protected as wilderness and more waterways determined eligible for wild and scenic protection, advocates must show up at public meetings, submit comments supporting Wilderness and Wild Rivers to the Forest Service, mobilize their friends to get involved, and get out there and explore these threatened wild places before its too late.
CalWild will email alerts for each forest in the coming months to generate specific public comments. If you live in the vicinity, we urge you to attend upcoming public information meetings about the draft plans. If you attend one of these meetings, be sure to mention that you support the wilderness protection proposed in Alternative C and all 870 miles of eligible Wild & Scenic Rivers, with some rivers and areas added (see above).
[There are currently no upcoming meetings]
For more information, please contact Steve Evans, CalWild’s Wild Rivers Consultant at firstname.lastname@example.org or call (916) 708-3155. To review the Forest Service’s draft Forest Plans and EIS, as well as for the full schedule of upcoming public meetings, visit for Forest Service’s website.
Wilderness and Wild & Scenic Rivers That We Can Save
Each summer during these revisions, CalWild will host a series of weekend camping trips to introduce our members and supporters to these beautiful wild places. Sign up to receive information on future trips as well as updates on the draft Forest Plan revisions when they are released for public review and comment.
CalWild and our allies are working to:
- Expand existing wilderness areas in the region to increase their ecological diversity, including additions to the Ansel Adams, White Mountains, Inyo Mountains, South Sierra, Domeland, Golden Trout, Monarch, Dinkey Lakes, Jenny Lakes, and John Muir Wilderness areas;
- Protect new wilderness areas such as Glass Mountain, Dexter Canyon, Cannell Peak, Stormy Canyon, Bear Mountain-Dinkey Dome, Sycamore Springs, and Devil Gulch-Ferguson Ridge;
- Protect key streams as wild and scenic rivers, including segments of Lee Vining Creek, Hot Creek, Lone Pine Creek, Salmon Creek, Trout Creek, lower Kern River, Kings River, Dinkey Creek, and the San Joaquin River; and
- Involve Native American Tribes, Latino groups, whitewater outfitters, kayakers and other non-traditional conservation partners in the public comments and planning processes through broad-based community organizing.
Some of the areas we are working to protect...
- Devil Gulch Potential Wilderness (Sierra National Forest)
- Dinkey Creek Potential Wild & Scenic River, Dinkey Dome Potential Addition to the Dinkey Lakes Wilderness, and Sycamore Springs Potential Wilderness (Sierra National Forest)
- Kings River Potential Wilderness and Wild & Scenic River (Sierra and Sequoia National Forests)
- Golden Trout Potential Wilderness Additions (Sequoia National Forest)
- Hot Creek Potential Wild & Scenic River (Inyo National Forest)
- Dexter Canyon Potential Wilderness and Wild & Scenic River (Inyo National Forest)
This 48,000 acre roadless area is composed of the steep slopes that rise up from the banks of the Wild South Fork Merced Wild & Scenic River from 1,398 feet to 6,989 feet in elevation. The area borders Yosemite National Park on the east. The roadless area is both a rare and extremely valuable priority for conservation because it is one of the lowest-elevation wild places in the southern Sierra, where most protected landscapes are sub-alpine or alpine and most low to mid-elevation areas have been mined, logged, developed or roaded. The Bishop Creek drainage in the roadless area contains a particularly fine stand of old-growth ponderosa pine forest, and two rare plants occur in the area. The Hite Cove Trail that parallels the South Fork is very popular for its spectacular spring wildflower displays.
Dinkey Creek flows for more than 27 miles from the high country of the Dinkey Lakes Wilderness, pass spectacular Dinkey Dome, and into a rugged canyon that ultimately leads all the way to the Kings River. Long threatened by a dam project, the middle segment of Dinkey Creek is a popular recreation destination for families from the Fresno/Clovis area, offering outstanding scenery appreciated by campers, anglers, hikers, and families simply escaping the summer heat. Expert whitewater kayakers consider lower Dinkey Creek to be world destination for class V (class VI is unrunnable) kayaking. Enter “Dinkey Creek kayaking” in your computer browser to view truly astounding examples of whitewater kayaking over the waterfalls of lower Dinkey Creek. The upper portion of the creek flows through the potential Dinkey Dome Addition, part of a more than 43,000-acre complex of potential additions to the Dinkey Lakes Wilderness. Lower Dinkey Creek flows through the 10,000-acre Sycamore Springs Potential Wilderness just upstream of the creek’s confluence with the North Fork Kings River.
Flowing through the deepest canyon in North America, the mighty Kings River forms the boundary between the Sierra and Sequoia National Forests. Much of the upper Kings is already protected in the Kings Canyon-Sequoia National Park, Monarch Wilderness, and as a Wild & Scenic River. But a 12-mile segment of the river downstream from these protected areas flows through the 28,000-acre unprotected Kings River roadless area. This segment of the Kings River is a state designated Wild Trout Stream and is a popular destination for whitewater boating. Establishment of the Kings River Special Management Area by Congress in 1987 shelved a dam project that threatened the river but it did not provide the area with the same level of protection as Wilderness. Protecting the river as Wild & Scenic and the roadless area as Wilderness would permanently protect an area that ranges from 1,000 feet elevation in the Sierra foothills to 12,000 feet elevation in the High Sierra. This not only protects a diverse area for a wide range of wildlife and plant species, it also provides protected habitat for climate change-induced migration of wildlife and plant species to higher elevation areas as our climate warms.
Adjacent to the existing Golden Trout Wilderness, these potential additions represent the largest complex of unroaded lands in the Sierra Nevada. They feature great ecological diversity due to their wildness, size, and elevations ranging from 3,000 feet along the North Fork Kern Wild & Scenic River to almost 10,000 feet atop Lookout Mountain. Protecting this area would preserve a continuous uninterrupted transition of ecosystems from the sagebrush and gray pine dominated landscape along the North Fork Kern to the conifer forests of the Kern Plateau. Durrwood Creek is an untouched tributary watershed that supports endangered golden trout and the upper North Fork Kern is home to the rare Kern River rainbow trout. The proposed Wilderness additions are also important summer range for deer migrating from Sequoia-Kings Canyon National Park. According to scientific reports, the protected and unprotected roadless lands in the North Fork Kern watershed (including the Golden Trout Wilderness and its potential additions) provide the river with a high level of biological integrity.
A state-designated Wild Trout Stream, Hot Creek is a popular destination for eastern Sierra visitors to view boiling hot springs and fish for wild trout, all framed by the magnificent backdrop of the eastern Sierra escarpment. Hot Creek is but one manifestation of the Long Valley Caldera, which erupted catastrophically 760,000 years ago. Pyroclastic ash from the eruption was carried by the wind eastward to what is now Kansas. A series of earthquakes and uplifting of the caldera floor by magma gathering deep underground in 1980 prompted government geologists to monitor the caldera. Meanwhile, bathing in Hot Creek was prohibited for safety reasons but visitors can still visit the thermal area along the creek and fish for wild trout downstream. Wild & Scenic protection of 3.5 miles of Hot Creek would preserve its outstanding scenic, recreational, wild trout fishery, geological, and ecological values. The proposed designation encompasses public lands managed by the Forest Service and Bureau of Land Management (BLM).
This 70,000 acre potential Wilderness is the only east-west mountain range in the eastern Sierra region. The spring-fed creeks, abundant meadows, and aspen groves in this relatively dry and desolate area is sustained by a stream of Pacific moisture that makes its way through Deadman Pass – a low point in the high Sierra crest directly west of Glass Mountain. Steep-walled canyons and high volcanic ridges add to the diversity of this truly unique ecological, recreational, and cultural resource, which is also an important migratory corridor and refuge for wildlife and plant species responding to climate change. Dexter Canyon and its tributaries have carved more than 25 miles of deeply incised rim-rock canyons reminiscent of the desert southwest. Dexter Canyon flows from a large meadow that supports aspen groves, willow thickets, bunch grasses, and sedges. A unique mix of Jeffrey, pinyon, and limber pine grow on the canyon slopes and rims, with occasional groves of snowbank aspen. Sagebrush tends to dominate the drier flats and slopes of the area. The entire area provides incredibly diverse habitat and is home to a wide variety of wildlife, including goshawk, greater sage grouse, black-backed woodpeckers, willow flycatchers, nesting golden eagles, badgers, abundant mule deer, and brook trout. A scientific assessment found that Dexter Canyon and its tributaries possess a high level of aquatic integrity.